After getting the new transmission in, I went for a drive and everything seemed normal until I got back to the house and heard a clicking I didn't remember hearing before. After another test drive, I isolated the transmission with the T-case, but the noise was still there. When I got home, I pulled the rear pinion, thinking one of the teeth was chipped.
Well, it was chipped and more, with 4 of the 9 teeth broken. Thinking back before pulling the transmission, I remember the drivetrain stalling for a split second when driving home one day. I wasn't 100% sure what had happened, but in retrospect it was clear I lost one tooth and it got pulled through the gear mesh and broke 3 more teeth.

It also broke the 3rd member case and trashed the ARB housing.


I performed an autopsy and determined one of the carrier bearing preload adjusters had been forcibly backed off, I'm guessing from some excessive torque on the pinion pushing the carrier over. The locking tab designed to hold the adjuster in place was bent and forced out of position. That is a lot of thrust load, but considering I have 300+lbft of engine torque x 5.7:1 first gear x 6:1 transfercase x 4.56 axle gears, it makes sense.
Cummins R2.8 diesel, ZF5, AtlasII, HP44/BB9, ARBs, coiled / linked suspension, 37" KO2s, full cage, bumpers, etc.
Build Thread:
http://www.coloradoclassicbroncos.com/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=5420Average 23.5 mpg, Best tank: 26.3 mpg