Max engine temp?

User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

So I put quite a few miles on my Bronco today. Many of them were hwy miles heading east on I-76 (so flat). With the heat today and running the cruising speed up to around 70 or so, RPM's between 2700-3000 on the 3 spd., my engine was running around 225F. I did back it down a bit to cruising closer to 65 and 2500 RPM and it dropped the temp down to around 220F. As soon as I would get off the hwy and drive typical city driving, the temp would drop down within 5 minutes to between 210-215.

It is my understanding that with EFI, it is supposed to run hotter but what is an acceptable range? I'm running 351W with Explorer EFI.
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
Digger
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 1282
Joined: Fri Jun 21, 2013 7:53 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Digger »

I have never seen any "hard" rules for MAX engine temp. I used to own several Ford Cologne V6s, which were notorious for cracked heads from over heating and most of mine ran hot.

I kept my engines below 220┬░F. Above that, and I was reducing power to lower temps. I would shutdown or idle an engine over 230┬░F. Most engines I've been around will start having pinging problems above 220┬░F.

That being said, we used to have a Chevy 350 race engine in the University's circle track car and that thing would come back to the pits with water temps over 250┬░F and oil temps 290┬░F+. Now I can't speak about it's longevity at those temps, but we never blew one up outright.

My Bronco's 351W currently is mildly built with cam, headers, intake, heads, etc. With a 195┬░F thermostat and a Champion (I think) aluminum radiator, it tends to be over-cooled. On hot summer days, engine temps vary between 185-195┬░F. Cold winter days, I'm lucky to hit 185┬░F.

Experience with my Ranger says that radiators make all the difference in the world and not all aftermarket units are equal. I chased cooling problems in that truck for years, only find out the super duper 3-core radiator I put it was no better than the crusty 1-core that came out. A different 3-core radiator would allow me to run WOT up Vail pass fully loaded all day.
Cummins R2.8 diesel, ZF5, AtlasII, HP44/BB9, ARBs, coiled / linked suspension, 37" KO2s, full cage, bumpers, etc.
Build Thread: http://www.coloradoclassicbroncos.com/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=5420

Average 23.5 mpg, Best tank: 26.3 mpg
User avatar
Rox Crusher
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 3980
Joined: Sun Oct 10, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Rox Crusher »

im going to guess that you may still have air trapped in your cooling system from changing parts, etc.

Put it nose up with radiator cap off.

Run it for a while to let it warm up enough to cycle the thermostat at least a couple of times. Keep topping the radiator off with coolant. When the thermostat closes, fill up the radiator and put the cap on and let it run a a bit longer and watch the gauge.

Make sure the suction tube is sitting on the bottom of the overflow / expansion reservoir so that it is always submerged in coolant. Fill reservoir up to hot level and drive it around to get the thermostat to cycle a couple times again.

Then let it cool off completely making sure to keep topping off the reservoir so the suction tube can only pull in coolant.

If you have a pocket of air in the cooling circuit, the temp sensor will read hot as it is getting a false reading from the steam.
1977 Sport, 351w OBDII EFI motor, 4R70W auto, 4:88 gears, ARB lockers, 3.5" suspension, 33" tires.
User avatar
Kinder
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 4372
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2010 9:03 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Kinder »

Stock gauge? Maybe check it against a 2nd source, IR temp gun could work.
Best to Date MPG: 26.6
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

kinder wrote:Stock gauge? Maybe check it against a 2nd source, IR temp gun could work.


I had the same thought and plugged my ODBII sensor in to get a reading. It was pretty close to the same reading.

I'm very skeptical that I have air in the system because it seems to react to the amount of "stress" I put on the engine. Lower the RPM, lower the temperature.

Was talking to Toolman and he has just added EFI with his 302 but bought a new Champion aluminum radiator. He said he has trouble getting to 195-200 degrees. I'm running a stock radiator. I also wasn't getting the high temps until I started running long distances at high speeds during really hot weather.

So should I be in the market for a new radiator to keep up with the heat?
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
EFI Guy
VENDOR
VENDOR
Posts: 443
Joined: Sun Dec 15, 2013 7:22 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by EFI Guy »

I don't like to see any higher than 220 with 195-205 being ideal.

At 65mph you should have plenty of air flow so it's not likely to be a fan/shroud problem. The T-stat is working if the temperature drops back down to normal. So, I'd say the radiator just isn't transferring heat well enough. Before replacing it look at it. If it has debris stuck in it try cleaning it. If a bunch of the fins are bent they can be straightened, but I'd just buy a new radiator at that point.
User avatar
Justin
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 6199
Joined: Sat Oct 09, 2010 11:04 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Justin »

I had the exact same problem. Dropped in a champion radiator for about $185 and haven't seen a temp above 195 since. Ran about 125 when my thermostat failed item.
User avatar
sykanr0ng
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 405
Joined: Thu Jan 22, 2015 12:46 am

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by sykanr0ng »

What kind of RPM's are you running in city driving?

I'm thinking your water pump is having problems with cavitation.
"You say overkill like it's a bad thing."
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

So I just got back from running some errands and around town I am staying around 200F. The water pump is brand new and I would say my RPM's vary around town but I would say I am consistently around 2200 or so. I can get the Champion radiator shipped with the 5.0 conversion for $195.

The radiator I have now looks to be in good shape -- the fins all look pretty good and there is nothing stuck in them. I had the inlet/outlet switched out when I converted to the 5.0 serpentine and the Radiator shop said it looked to be in good condition as well. Maybe it just can't keep up with my new engine with bigger balls!

I have a feeling I will be getting the new radiator. For the people running the Champion 3 core radiator. Where did you buy the new mounts? I was thinking of getting them from JBG as they also have dash knobs I need to buy. I've seen some write-ups on CB that some of the mounts have not worked for people out of the box on the Champion radiators... looking for insight if anyone has had success or problems.
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
Rox Crusher
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 3980
Joined: Sun Oct 10, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Rox Crusher »

intuition tells me it isn't the radiator
1977 Sport, 351w OBDII EFI motor, 4R70W auto, 4:88 gears, ARB lockers, 3.5" suspension, 33" tires.
User avatar
Justin
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 6199
Joined: Sat Oct 09, 2010 11:04 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Justin »

I used the 4 core radiator mounts and they fit the radiator perfectly. Worked great. Rox could be right, it may be something else, esp given that the radiator shop checked it out. 351w do have higher cooling needs, so the existing radiator could have been good enough for your 302, but just not quite enough for your new engine.
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

Rox Crusher wrote:intuition tells me it isn't the radiator


The overfill bottle has stayed full. When I replaced the thermostat a couple months ago, I burped the system, let it run up to temp and added coolant to get it full. I am just not sure their is enough air to give me false readings. When it overheated before, it created a lot of steam and actually blew the overflow lid off.

Any other ideas of what it could be? It seems like other folks are running the Champion and it cools considerably better?
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
ZOSO
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 3910
Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 4:58 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by ZOSO »

sykanr0ng wrote:
I'm thinking your water pump is having problems with cavitation.


Im wondering if this is your issue with the higher rpm.
Rob

74 Ranger EFI351w, 4r70w, ARB 5.13 9in, ARB 5.13D44, and a bunch of other goodies. Best of all the family memories.

04 Mustang Cobra, KenneBell 2.2 feeding a lot of boost on E85. Tire shredding machine

New project: 77 Bronco Ranger, body work and more body work.

Very little left of a 72 durango tan explorer sport
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

ZOSO wrote:
sykanr0ng wrote:
I'm thinking your water pump is having problems with cavitation.


Im wondering if this is your issue with the higher rpm.


I did put in a new water pump when I rebuilt the engine. I will try to run at a little higher RPM's around town and see if I notice the temps creeping up on me. However, changing a water pump that is brand new doesn't sound like a fun option...
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
Rox Crusher
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 3980
Joined: Sun Oct 10, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Rox Crusher »

Eck wrote:
ZOSO wrote:
sykanr0ng wrote:
I'm thinking your water pump is having problems with cavitation.


Im wondering if this is your issue with the higher rpm.


However, changing a water pump that is brand new doesn't sound like a fun option...


If it is the water pump rotating too fast, you may be able to just put a larger diameter pulley on it
1977 Sport, 351w OBDII EFI motor, 4R70W auto, 4:88 gears, ARB lockers, 3.5" suspension, 33" tires.
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

If it were the water pump cavitation, wouldn't the engine overheat on the hwy in "cooler" than 95F weather too?
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
Rox Crusher
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 3980
Joined: Sun Oct 10, 2010 4:36 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Rox Crusher »

Eck wrote:If it were the water pump cavitation, wouldn't the engine overheat on the hwy in "cooler" than 95F weather too?



If the impeller is spinning too fast it will cavitate / froth the coolant rather than pump it effeciently

at what combination of motor rpm and ambient temperature it becomes ineffective at doing it's job is impossible to estimate as there are too many variables

it could be that at a slower operating rpm, even in hotter ambient temps, it might be able to get the job done
1977 Sport, 351w OBDII EFI motor, 4R70W auto, 4:88 gears, ARB lockers, 3.5" suspension, 33" tires.
User avatar
Kinder
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 4372
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2010 9:03 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Kinder »

I'll add a couple of items that I think you should check; fan clutch and H2O/coolant percentage. The more items you are able to confirm are correct the smaller your list will get.
Best to Date MPG: 26.6
valentino
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 207
Joined: Sat Jan 22, 2011 8:35 am

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by valentino »

I need a new radiator,where can I buy a champion from?
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

kinder wrote:I'll add a couple of items that I think you should check; fan clutch and H2O/coolant percentage. The more items you are able to confirm are correct the smaller your list will get.


What am I looking for with the fan clutch? The coolant/water ratio is 50/50.
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

valentino wrote:I need a new radiator,where can I buy a champion from?


Look at their website for which one you need. Then Google the model number and you can find them through online vendors. I found the one I'm interested in on Jegs. I also found it about $30 cheaper through another online store but Jegs will price match that vendor.
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
sykanr0ng
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 405
Joined: Thu Jan 22, 2015 12:46 am

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by sykanr0ng »

Eck wrote:
kinder wrote:I'll add a couple of items that I think you should check; fan clutch and H2O/coolant percentage. The more items you are able to confirm are correct the smaller your list will get.


What am I looking for with the fan clutch? The coolant/water ratio is 50/50.


Increase the water to coolant, water is better at heat transfer than any of the anti-freezes.
"You say overkill like it's a bad thing."
User avatar
ZOSO
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 3910
Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 4:58 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by ZOSO »

valentino wrote:I need a new radiator,where can I buy a champion from?


I ordered mine off amazon.
Rob

74 Ranger EFI351w, 4r70w, ARB 5.13 9in, ARB 5.13D44, and a bunch of other goodies. Best of all the family memories.

04 Mustang Cobra, KenneBell 2.2 feeding a lot of boost on E85. Tire shredding machine

New project: 77 Bronco Ranger, body work and more body work.

Very little left of a 72 durango tan explorer sport
User avatar
Kinder
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 4372
Joined: Wed Sep 29, 2010 9:03 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Kinder »

The fan clutch should be controlled by a small thermostat, more importantly it shouldn't be worn out (i.e. bearings) and should operate correctly, spin freely when the temp is low and engage when the temp is high.
Best to Date MPG: 26.6
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

kinder wrote:The fan clutch should be controlled by a small thermostat, more importantly it shouldn't be worn out (i.e. bearings) and should operate correctly, spin freely when the temp is low and engage when the temp is high.


The bearings all seem to be fine. It spins fine but I am not sure about the thermostat thing. Is that a separate part? I just installed the fan clutch as part of the 5.0 front dress swap in.
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

So I replaced about a gallon of coolant today with water to increase the water to coolant ratio. I propped the nose up and ran the engine to temperature with the cap off. It didn't seem like their was air in the system, but I let it cycle a couple of time and as it overflowed into a bucket, I added a little bit more water.

I then went off on a test drive on I70 Westbound towards the mountains. I started at Wadsworth and got off at Youngsfield/ 32nd because it was clearly overheating. Once I got on to 32nd, I drove that home for about 7 miles going about 30 mph in 2nd gear keeping my RPM's up around 2700. The temperature maintained a "comfortable" zone of 200-210ish. Even sitting in my garage getting to a warm temperature. It seemed to idle above 200F.

I appreciate the suggestions-- I have a new radiator on order as it seems that this radiator is having a hard time keeping the temperature down during hot summer days. I am hopeful that my new aluminum radiator will have the same effect that it has had on Justin, Digger, and TOOLMAN.
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
ZOSO
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 3910
Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 4:58 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by ZOSO »

stupid question but in all your times tearing down the engine did you put the t stat in backwards?
Rob

74 Ranger EFI351w, 4r70w, ARB 5.13 9in, ARB 5.13D44, and a bunch of other goodies. Best of all the family memories.

04 Mustang Cobra, KenneBell 2.2 feeding a lot of boost on E85. Tire shredding machine

New project: 77 Bronco Ranger, body work and more body work.

Very little left of a 72 durango tan explorer sport
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

ZOSO wrote:stupid question but in all your times tearing down the engine did you put the t stat in backwards?


No. I've got about 600 miles on this since the rebuild including a day of wheeling in Moab. And I tested it yesterday and it opened up.
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
User avatar
ZOSO
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 3910
Joined: Mon Nov 15, 2010 4:58 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by ZOSO »

Doesnt mean it's not backwards. Mine was backwards and it still opened. Did this problem just start?
Rob

74 Ranger EFI351w, 4r70w, ARB 5.13 9in, ARB 5.13D44, and a bunch of other goodies. Best of all the family memories.

04 Mustang Cobra, KenneBell 2.2 feeding a lot of boost on E85. Tire shredding machine

New project: 77 Bronco Ranger, body work and more body work.

Very little left of a 72 durango tan explorer sport
User avatar
Eck
Official CCB Member
Official CCB Member
Posts: 2462
Joined: Thu Oct 25, 2012 8:33 pm

Re: Max engine temp?

Post by Eck »

ZOSO wrote:Doesnt mean it's not backwards. Mine was backwards and it still opened. Did this problem just start?


Yes
69 Wagon, 351W, Explorer EFI & Serpentine, ZF5, 35" tires, 3.5 SL, 2 BL, WARN 8274
Post Reply